It is never a dull week at EPH. As a future teacher I am getting a lot of practice rearranging schedules and lesson plans due to un-forseen circumstances. This past week alone we had a snow day, salt surveys and a little break out in the cold while the fire department investigated for a fire. Thankfully, there was no fire! Although, this seems chaotic, I think it is a valuable experience because we as teachers can't control the weather and all the circumstances at the school. However, we can learn to "roll with the punches" and adapt to the changes as necessary. After all, isn't being prepared, thinking on our feet and being inventive part of the job?
I did get to start teaching my unit on Macbeth this week. Both days seemed to have gone well. My only issue was during the discussion only a few students were talking about the topic. I tried asking if anyone had a different opinion or comments on the existing ones, re-explaining questions, wait time, calling out students only to hear I agree with so and so with no explanation. I can honestly say I was a little frustrated. However, in the process I made a game time decision and switched up the activities. They did their work while I walked around and talked to them, wondering how the discussion went so wrong. I reflected on how I could have made them more comfortable to talk, or if they even understood the whole point. I had a lot of questions raging in my mind. After class, I read their responses to the question and they all had very different insightful opinions. So I came to the conclusion that they understood the point because they all had an opinion but they were not comfortable speaking it out in the class. I wondered if maybe it was the topic or if they were not comfortable with me. My CT teacher and I went over the lesson plan later that day. She thought it went well except for a few minor tweaks. I asked her about the discussion and what she does when it falls apart. She told me it happens. Sometimes she has them go very well and other days she wonders what went wrong. She did think I handled it well changing up the plan. But I left thinking if this is a constant issue, why; topics, attitudes, moods, time (period), atmosphere etc.. I still don't have an answer but I will forever be prepared with a back up plan if a discussion does not go well.
Lisa, leading a discussion is definitely something that makes me nervous because sometimes even as a student I don't always feel like I have something to say (even with my most favorite teachers!). I'm not totally sure what your lesson was like, but giving students time to write first and then scaffolding the sharing of the writing might be something to think about. So with this, each student might free write a response to your question, underline a sentence they want to share, and then each person shares their one sentence. It's safer since you just have to read off your paper and everyone is doing it. Next time, you gradually increase from one sentence to two (or three or four)and maybe have the students write down a line that another classmate says that they want to respond to. Maybe taking it slower, step-by-step will help them feel more comfortable and confident with sharing their thoughts! Good luck!
ReplyDeleteLisa- I totally hear you on the planning and scheduling issues! We had two snow days, two days of testing that spilled into three for some kids, and trying to rearrange and still engage! It's tough, but it's such a valuable lesson to learn early on and to help you learn how to change up a lesson on the spot and get the same result! It's great that this is happening now, so when you start teaching you'll know exactly what to do!
ReplyDeleteLisa I know what you mean about Macbeth! The minute Shakespeare was mentioned it was like the complaints were uncontrollable...they are not interested in giving it a chance. Hopefully us trying the graphic novel will bring a little excitement.
ReplyDeleteLisa: Brittany's advice is top notch! I was going to suggest the same thing. Use writing as a way to ease students into talking. You'll notice that they are more confident to share their voice when they already know what they are going to say. Maybe something to think about as you move forward is teaching Socratic Seminar as a method of classroom discussion. If you're coming to the RIWP Spring Conference on March 9, there's a session on Socratic Seminar that might be of use!
ReplyDelete